Guardii Advisory · Research briefing no. 2Sport

Bettor abuse of athletes: the 2026 evidence

Abuse and threats from people who bet on games are now measured, common and documented by the athletes' own associations. The worst of it arrives in private messages, where today's tools do not reach.

Executive summary

  • It is measured, and it is common. 46% of Division I men's basketball players received negative or threatening messages from someone who bet on their game.3 81 of 100 MLB players surveyed had been confronted by bettors.7 66% of AFL players received some form of online abuse in the past 12 months.1
  • The worst of it is private. Of AFL players targeted, 2 in 3 received abuse by direct message and 1 in 3 received threats of physical harm or death.1 In tennis, gamblers made up 77% of direct abuse, against 40% on open social media.5
  • Athletes rarely report it. About 4% of AFL players sought support or reported.1 87% of NRL players facing targeted abuse did not report it.2
  • Incumbent tools watch public posts, and wait for the athlete for everything else. Comment moderation deletes comments. Private-message services work on reports the athlete forwards, or on message requests from strangers.111213
  • Leagues and regulators are moving. In September 2026 the five major US leagues and their unions asked regulators in 35 states for lifetime bans. Massachusetts runs its own harassment intake, and a New York bill would bar bettors convicted of harassing athletes.182022
  • The defensible control sits on the athlete's phone. Detection runs on the device, nobody can read the messages, the athlete decides where anything goes, and the evidence is ready when the athlete chooses to escalate.

01The scale of bettor abuse

In 2025 and 2026 the athletes' own bodies measured bettor abuse. In February 2026 the NCAA surveyed 493 schools: 51% of Division I men's basketball student-athletes reported social media abuse based on their athletic performance, and 46% received "negative or threatening messages from someone who bet on their game".3 An earlier NCAA survey, released in November 2025, put betting-related abuse of the same group at 36%.4

In an August 2026 survey of 100 MLB players by The Athletic, 81 said they had been confronted by bettors.7 In tennis, the governing bodies found that gamblers accounted for 42% of verified abuse in 2025, and 59% of the most serious cases.6

In Australia the players' associations have published their own numbers. The AFL Players' Association's July 2026 report found that 66% of AFL players received some form of online abuse in the past 12 months, against 27% of the general population, and that 31% of AFLW players were targeted.1 The RLPA's Players' Pulse 2025 found that 13% of NRL players faced targeted abuse.2

Figure 1Athletes reporting abuse, by survey

MLB players confronted by bettors 81% AFL players receiving online abuse 66% D-I men's basketball: abuse over performance 51% D-I men's basketball: threats from bettors 46% D-I men's basketball: betting abuse (Nov 2025) 36% AFLW players targeted online 31% NRL players facing targeted abuse 13% Bettor-specific measure All online abuse
Sources: The Athletic, August 2026;7 AFLPA Insights and Impact Report, Edition 5, July 2026;1 NCAA, February 2026 and November 2025;34 RLPA, The Players' Pulse 2025.2 Each bar is a different survey, population and question, and the bars should not be compared as one series.

02Where it arrives: the private channel

The most important finding in the AFLPA report is about the channel. Of AFL players who were targeted, 2 in 3 received abuse through direct messages. 1 in 3 received threats of physical harm or death, and 1 in 5 faced a coordinated pile-on from multiple accounts.1 The report calls the online environment "one of the most significant external risk exposures facing players".

Bettors in particular lean to the private channel. In their 2024 data, the WTA and ITF found that "angry gamblers made up the vast majority of direct abuse (77%)", a higher level than on open-source social media, where they made up 40%.5 One Division I player put it more simply to the NCAA: "they always DM me."4

Figure 2Gamblers' share of abuse against tennis players

2024, by channel Direct abuse 77% Open-source social media 40% 2025, by severity Most serious cases 59% All verified abuse 42%
Sources: WTA and ITF, June 2025;5 ITF, WTA, AELTC and USTA 2025 findings.6 Each figure is the share of abuse that came from gamblers within that channel or category. It is not the share of all abuse that arrived in each channel.

Private messages are not only social media inboxes. In a study of 85 athletes in one US conference, harassment arrived through social posts (9.4%), direct messages (4.7%) and texts (3.5%).17 In September 2026 a WNBA player received racist text messages from a contractor's employee; the sender was fired and banned from all league games and events.25 The same month, an NFL quarterback's family received threats by direct message on three platforms after a loss.25

Measurement has not caught up. A February 2026 paper from Safe Sport International and Sportradar notes that "much of our understanding of online abuse has been based on monitoring and surveillance of content and commentary on social media platforms".16

Most published abuse counts measure public comments. The players' own surveys say the threats arrive in the inbox.

03What athletes report, and what they do not

Abuse that arrives privately reaches an integrity or welfare team only if the athlete passes it on. Most do not. The AFLPA found that about 4% of AFL players and about 8% of AFLW players sought support or reported the incident, while 2 in 3 targeted players reported a negative effect.1 The RLPA found that 87% of NRL players facing targeted abuse did not report it, and named the barrier: a belief that reporting will not lead to meaningful action.2

Figure 3Abused against reported, AFL and AFLW players

AFL players Received online abuse 66% Sought support or reported about 4% AFLW players Targeted online 31% Sought support or reported about 8%
Source: AFLPA Insights and Impact Report, Edition 5, July 2026.1 Reporting rates as stated by the AFLPA; see section 7 on the base.

A threat, a sextortion demand or an approach for inside information is evidence. If the athlete deletes it or keeps it to themselves, nobody can act on it.

04What the incumbent tools reach

On their own published terms, the products on the market moderate public comments, or take private messages the athlete forwards.

Where a private-message option has been offered and counted, few athletes have used it.

1 of 2,032

Players monitored at March Madness 2025 who used the automated Direct Message service.

NCAA, June 2025

28 players

Sent 56 reports of concerning communication in 2024, from about 8,300 tennis players covered.

WTA and ITF, June 2025

1 in 5

Instagram accounts with over 10,000 followers that had turned on Hidden Words, October 2022.

Meta, 2022

The NCAA's March Madness 2025 programme logged 3,161 abusive public posts and 10 police referrals; one player used the private-message service.8 Reading abuse and forwarding it, or handing over account access, is a heavy ask. Messages from accounts the athlete follows, and anything by SMS, WhatsApp or iMessage, sit outside a filter on stranger requests.

05Leagues and regulators are moving

The ban power is moving to regulators, and every ban needs evidence: the leagues are asking for it, Massachusetts takes it, and New York's bill turns on a conviction. That evidence sits in the athlete's private messages, and today it reaches a regulator only as a screenshot the athlete chose to take.

06What a defensible control looks like

A control for this channel must put threats and approaches in front of the right people in time to act, without making the league, club or school the party that reads its athletes' messages. In our view it needs these properties.

  1. It runs on the athlete's own phone. Detection happens on the device. Nobody can read the messages: not the club, not the league, not the vendor.
  2. It covers the channels the abuse uses. Direct messages, texts and messaging apps, from strangers and from accounts the athlete already follows.
  3. It needs no account handover. The athlete gives no password or account access to anyone.
  4. It acts when the message arrives. Explicit abuse and threats are flagged at once. Manipulation, such as a "fan" working toward a request for inside information or a sextortion script, is detected and named, so the athlete can see what is happening.
  5. The athlete controls routing. Nothing leaves the phone unless the athlete chooses. Routes are agreed in advance and care comes first: distress to player welfare, corrupt approaches to integrity, threats to security or police.
  6. Evidence is ready when the athlete chooses to escalate. Messages are preserved as they arrived, with a chain of custody designed to meet investigators' standards, ready for an integrity unit, a regulator or police without handing over a phone.
  7. The organisation holds a record of protection and no message content. Control offered, uptake, alerts raised, escalations the athlete chose. There is no archive of messages to breach or to be discovered.
  8. Players are onboarded in person. Section 4 shows an opt-in link reaches almost no one. The players' association or club runs onboarding.
What this design does not settle

Each regulator sets its own evidence threshold for an exclusion, and none has yet said what a structured submission from an athlete's phone must contain. Whether a duty to act follows once an organisation is told of a threat, and what it must then do, are questions for each organisation's own counsel before launch.

07Methodology and limitations

Sources

  1. AFL Players' Association, Insights and Impact Report, Edition 5, July 2026. aflplayers.com.au. General population comparison: AIC, Cybercrime in Australia 2024, as cited.
  2. Rugby League Players' Association, The Players' Pulse 2025, released 21 January 2026, 800+ NRL and NRLW players, p. 10.
  3. NCAA, "DI men's basketball student-athletes experiencing increased social media harassment, NCAA survey reveals", 5 February 2026. ncaa.org.
  4. NCAA, "NCAA study finds over one-third of DI men's basketball student-athletes harassed by bettors", 18 November 2025. ncaa.org.
  5. WTA and ITF, abuse report, 16 June 2025. wtatennis.com.
  6. ITF, WTA, AELTC and USTA, findings of the online abuse support service, 2025. wtatennis.com.
  7. The Athletic, survey of MLB players on bettors, 28 August 2026, via Yahoo Sports.
  8. NCAA, 2025 March Madness Signify data, 10 June 2025. ncaa.org.
  9. NCAA, "NCAA to assist FBI in protecting student-athletes from sextortion and related crimes", 10 August 2026. ncaa.org.
  10. Meta, "Protecting people on Instagram from abuse", 20 October 2022. about.fb.com. Meta, "Keeping athletes safe this summer", May 2021. about.fb.com.
  11. Social Protect, Frequently asked questions. socialprotect.ai.
  12. Signify Group, Threat Matrix terms of service, last updated 1 January 2026. signify.ai.
  13. Fanatics, "Bad actors face account suspension or termination for online abuse and threats", 25 June 2026. fanaticsinc.com.
  14. UCI, "The UCI appoints Signify Group to help protect cycling family against online abuse", 2026. uci.org.
  15. IC360, "Mountain West to utilize Alert360 to combat athlete harassment", 7 October 2024. ic360.io. Athlete Alert (US Integrity with RealResponse), 2023, via Sports Handle.
  16. Safe Sport International and Sportradar, Online Abuse of Athletes, February 2026. sportanddev.org.
  17. Journal of Issues in Intercollegiate Athletics, vol. 19, iss. 1, art. 14, study of 85 athletes in one conference (abstract). scholarcommons.sc.edu.
  18. Joint statement of the NFL, NBA, MLB, NHL, MLS and their players' associations, 15 September 2026, as reported by ESPN, Deseret News and PhillyVoice.
  19. NBA, WNBA, NBPA and WNBPA follow-up to state regulators, September 2026, as reported by Yahoo Sports and Covers.
  20. Massachusetts Gaming Commission, Bet On Respect, 31 August 2026. massgaming.com. Athlete harassment submission portal: massgaming.com. 205 CMR 152.
  21. Sports Betting Dime, "Sports betting bans for athlete harassment have yet to lead to any official action", updated 16 June 2026. sportsbettingdime.com.
  22. New York State Senate, S7482C. nysenate.gov. New York State Assembly, A7903C. nysenate.gov.
  23. Protect College Sports Act (S. 4668), passed the Senate 77-22 on 28 September 2026, s 113(c). legalsportsbetting.com.
  24. Covers, Indiana college player prop ban rejected, 24 September 2026. covers.com.
  25. Incident reports, September 2026: Yahoo Sports, 3 September 2026 (text messages to a WNBA player); Pro Football Network, 28 September 2026 (threats to an NFL player's family).

This briefing is general research, not legal advice. It does not take account of any organisation's circumstances, and legislation, regulator rules and survey findings should be checked against their current versions before reliance. Guardii Advisory, October 2026.